This afternoon, I visited a building across campus for a lunchtime meeting. It’s not a familiar place, so I don’t have a sense of who comes and goes during the day, but just then the lobby was fairly deserted. Even the security guard was away from his desk; in fact, he’d taken the elevator to another floor just before I got there. I pushed the button and waited.
Behind me, I heard a man say “Hey. . . you’re beautiful.”
I turned my head very slightly to look out of the corner of my eye. There wasn’t anyone else nearby, just a man seated at his ease in the small lounge area. “Thank you,” I said with a curt nod, and faced the elevator again.
A pause, and then the man laughed ingratiatingly and said he didn’t mean any harm by it.
I didn’t answer, but I was thinking I know. And also, I don’t care what you mean.
Let’s review. I walk into a strange place and hear a man possibly addressing me. I look very carefully but not overtly to see if he was addressing me, so that if he wasn’t looking directly at me he might not see my glance and decide to target me for attention or ridicule. I then answer him coolly but politely, a tone that in my experience corresponds with a low incidence of escalation (yelling, demanding my attention, following, that sort of thing). And in the few seconds it takes for me to make nice, I have time to size up the situation and decide that the man was not using an aggressive posture or tone. More importantly, I didn’t feel that he was a threat, and after a decade of living and walking alone in major cities, I trust my instincts.
So yeah, I felt reasonably secure that he didn’t mean any harm by it. But I still don’t fucking care what he thinks. And he could just have well have kept it to himself; my day would have been better without it.
On my old blogs, some time ago, I would frequently describe my encounters with strangers out in the world: the young man who followed me to show me cat pictures on his phone, the young man who followed me until I lied that I was meeting my boyfriend for dinner, the older man who followed me while asking questions about my ethnic heritage, and so on. Early on, I didn’t have the language to deconstruct why these episodes troubled me and what they implied about the world I moved around in as a woman, so the stories would come bubbling out part complaint and part humorous vignettes: ugh, men on the street, amirite? But telling the stories helped me find words for what I could feel was wrong–it wasn’t fair that an imaginary boyfriend’s feelings mattered more than mine, that I was supposed to feel flattered but I just felt scared and angry, that neither verbal or nonverbal cues could navigate those conversations the way I wanted them to go (away from me).
I don’t usually tell these stories anymore unless they are particularly funny. I understand more of the sticky social web that strings these behaviors together with others that target women. I don’t need the catharsis as much. And, to be frank, it happens less often as I get older, fatter, and more inked. (I was wearing a modest tattoo-concealing cardigan today; I suppose that was my mistake.)
I’ve had worse, lots of us have had worse, but I’m picking on this poor mild means-no-harm guy today because he presented a textbook illustration of two capital-T TRUTHS I’ve read recently.
One is from Shakesville, in which Melissa McEwan writes about her experience walking with her husband to their car, and all the things that she sees that her husband doesn’t see. She unpacks all of the involuntary mental work she does silently: noticing a man in the parking lot, guessing his trajectory and point of interception, intuiting what he wants and whether he’s likely to be violent. To paraphrase one of the commenters, Do you have any idea how much RAM it takes to run these processes all the time? I like that metaphor: some of us, through experience, develop a few programs that hum unobtrusively in the background whenever we are in public. I’ve sometimes observed that if I walk home when my judgement is impaired–when I’m very tired, or a little drunk–I feel hyper-aware, like all my senses are escalated. Maybe it’s more accurate to say that I’m just running these processes less elegantly, so they take over more of my perception.
The other was in the wake of some loser writing about how hot Sophia Vergara is at 42. (She is! I get it! Save it for your blog, paid writerman!) At New Republic, Rebecca Traister wrote about how sick and tired she is of male writers, male pundits, male everyone and women too weighing in on whether they think this woman or that woman is sexy. She quotes a story about Amy Poehler that Tina Fey tells in Bossypants:
Amy Poehler, then new to “Saturday Night Live,” was engaging in some loud and unladylike vulgarity in the writers’ room when the show’s then-star Jimmy Fallon jokingly told her to cut it out, saying, “It’s not cute! I don’t like it!” In Fey’s retelling, Poehler “went black in the eyes for a second, and wheeled around on him,” forcefully informing him: “I don’t fucking care if you like it.”
This anecdote stayed with me long after I read Bossypants, and I surely already possessed great barren fields of fucks to give, but it actually did help a great deal that I had this recent reminder. It’s an excellent mantra, and I recommend repeating it until it sticks to something, anything:
I don’t fucking care if you like it. Really, I don’t. Unless we’re dating, or good friends, or I’ve done something deliberate and spectacular to my physical appearance (fantastic makeup?) or with my physical appearance . . . perhaps this is a good time to relink to this classic Lindy West manual of when to compliment women?
3 thoughts on “On not caring if you like it”
This kills me. Wish I’d noticed how harmful it was when I was younger, instead of having to wait until I was a dad. So many people tell my daughter is that she’s absolutely gorgeous, which is NOT the kind of thing I want my child to hear. Brilliant, strong, bad-ass; those compliments are fantastic. Her looks are genetic; they’re not something she’s actively doing or worthy of singling out.
It’s really, really tough to change the conversation about our littlest littles. Socially Approved Baby Conversation is ironclad; now that so many of my friends are starting families I often find myself on the verge of saying things like “Boy or girl?” even though I really don’t care, it’s your baby, I’m interested in your baby’s life and gender is only one piece of that, but that is one of the things One is Supposed to Say. And though there are many things that might make a specific beautiful baby remarkable–clear eyes and curiosity, bubbly laughter and cheerful nature, beatific calm–as a stranger, I couldn’t really walk up to you and say, “Wow, your baby is super engaged and curious!” I mean, maybe as a stranger I shouldn’t walk up and say anything to you at all, but I can forgive people losing their heads about cute babies.
It’s going to get real interesting when she’s a gorgeous, brilliant, strong, badass little girl. People will still comment on her beauty–and this I find a little less forgivable, because I remember squirming under the attention as a little kid–and you’ll have to pick a script.
Do you teach her to say thank you to the nice stranger? That’s what I learned, and I don’t love it, but then you’ll have to teach her to take compliments all over again when she’s a teenager and her social script is to refuse praise, deny her beauty, and writhe in self loathing. (As I recall, anyway.)
Do you yourself say “Thanks, but she’s also smart/hilarious/talented!” and tell a charming anecdote to illustrate, which is a nice moment but truly none of a stranger’s business?
Do you just say “Thank you” and end the conversation and move on with your life and rely on your family and friends to help reinforce what matters at another time and place?
I don’t envy you, but I’m also not worried about you. She’s obviously a great little kid, so, keep on. : )
[…] also funny because the list so recognizably me. Rule #3 became a deeply rooted self-preservation instinct. Rule #4 is the north star of my love life. Rule #5, of course, refers to Kipling’s Just-So […]